The Living Herbarium: Many Hands Make Godzilla

January 14, 2016

Article originally published in The Leaflet (May 2014) by Brian Witte, PhD, BRIT Research Associate

There is a stereotype of the scientist as a lone genius, laboring in obscurity until their “Eureka!” moment changes the world. If Hollywood is to be believed, this Eureka moment is usually followed by the destruction of Tokyo and/or New York by a giant robot/genetic mutant/superstorm. In reality, we have a tragic lack of giant robots, and nothing that we’ve done in the herbarium has (yet) threatened a major metropolitan area. We also rely heavily on collaboration, rather than solitary toil. In fact, I would venture to say that collaboration is the fundamental characteristic of science.


NOT what we do…exactly.

Nowhere is this more on display than in the herbarium at BRIT. Over the past month, I have been assisting on a project to make some of the specimens from the Philecology Herbarium available online. I’ll have more on the process and challenges of digitizing a natural history collection in a future column. For now, just know that the essential elements include a high-resolution photograph of the actual sheet stored in the herbarium and a faithful transcription of the text on the sheet. The photograph is needed to document the plant and its morphological characteristics. The transcription is needed so that a researcher can find the photograph by searching for genus, species, location, date of collection, or any of a set of other criteria.


Digitization is super fun!

In aggregate, the herbarium at BRIT is an amazing repository of information. It is also a densely interwoven network of literally millions of hours of work by staff and volunteers. One rather homely specimen that beautifully illustrates the collaborative nature of plant identification is below.

Witte Godzilla


The original specimen was collected in 1948 by Dr. Lloyd Herbert Shinners, the original director of the herbarium. He identified it as Portulaca pilosa. Two months later, he changed his determination to Portulaca parvula. Thirty-five years later, a scientist working on a flora of the southeastern US reaffirmed the original identification of P. pilosa. One more confirmation of this identification was added in 1992 when the specimen was examined by Dr. J.F. Matthews of the University of North Carolina-Charlotte, as part of the definitive project on plant identification in North America.

Not all herbarium specimens are formally examined by experts or play a role in confirming the definition of a species, as this one has. It is, however, demonstrative of how one small plant can pass through many hands as it plays a role in our greater understanding of how plants are related and species defined.

Another element of collaboration is evident just in the sheer numbers of specimens housed in the BRIT herbarium. Although Dr. Shinners, the founder, collected over 33,469 specimens in his career, he is responsible for less than less than 2% of the hoard. Dr. Mahler, who catalyzed the founding of BRIT and oversaw the transfer of custody of the herbarium from Southern Methodist University to a new independent foundation, contributed over 10,000 specimens – less than 1% of the collection. The largest single donor to the collection is probably Dr. Robert Kral who developed and curated the herbarium at Vanderbilt University. BRIT is now housing his collection, which includes over 100,000 specimens collected just by Dr. Kral. Still, his contributions are less than 10% of the total.

The herbarium is remarkable in how much has been contributed by amateurs and non-specialists. This specimen below, for example, was collected by Mike Ragain in 1986, then an undergraduate student in the class of Dr. George Diggs at Austin College. Once this project is finished and his specimen record becomes available online, this collection will be available to anyone anywhere in the world. Whatever other contributions Mike has made to the world since grunge was an exciting new genre of music, he has made a small, concrete contribution to the study of plant taxonomy, ecology, and distribution.

Witte Godzilla

Further, all of these specimens, from the prolific Dr. Kral as well as from the neophyte Mike, are still extant due to the efforts of the curators who have kept the collection in excellent condition, the volunteers who transferred many of the collections from a plant press to archival-quality paper, and us hapless peons who are working on digitizing the collection. Each of us has a part in deepening our understanding of the natural world, however unglamorous. And you can be sure that if the BRIT Herbarium ever succeeds in laying waste to an obscure hamlet, many hands will have contributed to making possible that glorious day.


We’re more Voltron than Godzilla, and that’s PRETTY COOL.

Leave A Response

Restricted HTML

  • Allowed HTML tags: <a href hreflang> <em> <strong> <cite> <blockquote cite> <code> <ul type> <ol start type> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd> <h2 id> <h3 id> <h4 id> <h5 id> <h6 id>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Web page addresses and email addresses turn into links automatically.

Related Articles

The Living Herbarium: Instructions for Life

Article originally published in The Leaflet (April 2014) by Brian Witte, PhD, BRIT Research Associate (Disclaimer: The technical aspects of this article are dramatically simplified in the interests of communicating with an audience entirely unfamiliar with molecular biology. Send me an email ( ) if you would like a deeper explanation.) We like to repeat, loudly and often, that there are over 1 million plant specimens in the Philecology Herbarium at BRIT. It’s a nice, big, round number, and it sounds cool when tour groups come through. What if I told you that as imposing as that number sounds, the real number is closer to a thousand billion (1,000,000,000,000) plants*? The goal of a herbarium is to preserve plants. The ideal specimen, in many respects, has all the essential...
Read More >

The Sweep of Time

Article originally submitted for The Leaflet (June 2014) by Brian Witte, PhD, BRIT Research Associate Most of us live in the moment. Paycheck-to-paycheck, living for the weekend, summer vacation, twitter updates. Updates now are measured in seconds. America, too, is a young nation. Few places west of the Appalachians boast buildings over 150 years old, and most of us live in suburbs built in the decades following World War II. So much around us is new…even our landscapes are new, transformed by mechanized farming, car culture, and introduced species. That’s not entirely news, and it’s not entirely new, either. Look, for example, at this sheet I recently encountered while tidying up a database of digitized herbarium specimens. Click to enlarge and read labels. This was one of the last colle...
Read More >

A 54-Year Celebration

The Journal of the Botanical Research Institute of Texas ( JBRIT ) is celebrating its 54th year of continuous publication. It all started when Lloyd H. Shinners —a member of the Southern Methodist University (SMU) faculty and a prolific botanical researcher and writer who wanted to edit his work and the work of others—founded and published the first two issues of Sida, Contributions to Botany on November 23, 1962. He named the journal for a genus ( Sida ) of yellow-flowered plants of the mallow or cotton family (Malvaceae), distributed throughout the world and especially common in Texas. Shinners served as editor and publisher until his death in 1971, after which William F. Mahler, professor of botany at SMU, inherited the journal and continued to edit and privately publish it. Barney Lips...
Read More >

Recycling Rocks!

Mixed-stream recycling is pretty amazing. We get to throw all of our recyclables into one bin, and then — POOF! — they magically get taken away and sorted elsewhere. No more icky sorting of paper from soda cans, milk jugs from mason jars! But have you ever wondered how the sorting ACTUALLY HAPPENS and WHO DOES IT?
Read More >